Is Honey Really Healthier Than Sugar?

Both honey and sugar are carbohydrates made up primarily of two simple sugars: glucose and fructose.

However, their composition differs slightly.

Depending on the source, honey contains about 80-85% sugars: 38-40% fructose and 30-35% glucose. The rest (15-20%) is mostly water and trace amounts of pollen, micronutrients and other compounds.

On the other hand, sugar contains 100% sugars: 50% glucose and 50% fructose chemically bound together as sucrose.

While both are used to add sweetness to food and drinks, honey is slightly sweeter than sugar due to its higher fructose content (fructose is sweeter than glucose).

Now that we have the basics down, let’s take a look at how other components compare between the two.

Nutritional Composition

Here’s how the nutritional content of 1 tablespoon each of honey and sugar compare:

Per tablespoon, honey packs more calories than sugar, which might sound like a red flag, especially if you’re watching your weight.

But because honey is sweeter than sugar, people often use less of it to get the same sweetness. This means that the calorie difference ends up being small.

From a nutrition perspective, honey clearly brings more to the table.

While sugar is 100% pure sucrose, offering just energy and no nutrients, honey contains trace amounts of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants.

This is why sugar is often labeled “empty calories” because it offers no nutritional value.

But…

Honey isn’t all the same.

These trace amounts of micronutrients and antioxidants are mostly found in raw, unprocessed honey.

When honey is heated, pasteurized or filtered (which many brands are, to extend its shelf life), these beneficial compounds are significantly reduced.

In addition, the source of the honey also influences the quantity of these compounds.

Effect on Blood Sugar

When you eat carbohydrates, your body breaks them down into glucose, which is absorbed into your bloodstream and causes your blood sugar levels to rise.

How quickly this happens is measured by something called the glycemic index (GI)—a scale from 0 to 100 that tells you how fast a food raises your blood sugar.

Here’s how foods are ranked:

• Low GI (0–55): Slow, steady rise in blood sugar.

• Moderate GI (56–69): Moderate rise in blood sugar.

• High GI (70–100): Fast spike in blood sugar.

Why does this matter?

Eating high-GI foods causes quick blood sugar spikes, triggering your body to release a large amount of insulin to bring the blood sugar levels back down.

Over time, frequent spikes and crashes can lead to energy dips, increased cravings, and a higher risk of insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes.

In general, the lower the GI of a food, the better it is for blood sugar control and steady energy levels throughout the day.

Where do honey and sugar stand?

• Sugar has a GI of around 65–70, depending on the source.

• Honey’s GI varies widely—from as low as 32 to as high as 85, depending on factors like its fructose-to-glucose ratio, the type of flowers the bees visited, and whether it’s raw or processed.

Honeys with a higher percentage of fructose tend to have a lower GI, because fructose is absorbed more slowly than glucose and doesn’t cause as sharp a rise in blood sugar.

This means that some types of honey (especially raw, high-fructose varieties) can lead to a more moderate blood sugar rise than sugar.

One study found that raw honey led to significantly lower blood sugar and insulin levels compared to the same amount of sugar, both in healthy people and those with type 2 diabetes.

This suggests that depending on the type, honey may have a milder effect on blood sugar.

Health Benefits

Before the mass production of sugar had begun, honey was the only natural sweetener available for use.

For a long time, honey has been used not only as a sweetener but also as a natural remedy.

In fact, there’s a whole branch of alternative medicine now called apitherapy that uses honey and other bee products to treat a variety of health conditions.

Some of the health benefits of honey have been scientifically proven including:

1. Rich in antioxidants

Raw honey, especially the darker varieties, is rich in antioxidants like flavonoids and phenolic acids.

These compounds help fight oxidative stress that damages your cells and leads to chronic inflammation, which is linked to several diseases like heart disease and cancer.

2. Natural cough suppressant

Several studies show honey is more effective than over-the-counter cough syrups at easing nighttime coughing in children over 1 year old.

It helps by soothing throat irritation, reducing inflammation and suppressing the cough reflex.

Just 1-2 teaspoons before bed can help ease a persistent cough for better sleep.

3. Wound & burn healing

Honey has been used for centuries to treat wounds, burns, and ulcers thanks to its antibacterial and antifungal properties.

Manuka honey in particular (a type of honey from New Zealand) has been reported to be effective at healing stubborn wounds that didn’t respond to conventional treatment.

Not A Magic Bullet

While honey has clear benefits, studies indicate that most of these health benefits are only achieved when high amounts are consumed—around 50-80g per day.

That’s roughly 3–5 tablespoons daily, which adds a significant amount of sugar and may not be practical (or healthy) for most people.

So, while honey can support health in small ways, it’s not a magic bullet and shouldn’t be viewed as such.

Final Verdict

So, is honey healthier than sugar?

Short answer: yes, but just barely.

While honey does have additional nutrients, they’re so minimal that it can’t be considered a health food.

Realistically, you’d need to consume large quantities of honey daily to get substantial nutritional and health benefits, and that’s not ideal from a calorie or sugar standpoint.

Honey is the “better” choice if you’re looking for a more natural sweetener with a few potential health perks.

But at the end of the day, it’s still high in sugar and calories. When consumed in excess, it poses the same health risks as sugar.

The World Health Organization recommends keeping added sugars (including honey) below 10% of your daily calories (that’s about 6-9 teaspoons (25-36g) for most adults).

So, should you swap sugar for honey?

Sure, if you like the taste or want a less processed option. But be careful to use it in moderation too.

And one last tip: choose raw, unprocessed honey to get the most benefits. Watch out for fake honey, which is often diluted with cheap syrups and offers zero health perks.

Thanks for reading! I hope you found something valuable :)

To get more actionable tips like these, consider joining other health-curious friends like you by signing up below.